Books Review: Divergent and Insurgent by Veronica Roth

Title: Divergent
Insurgent
Author: Veronica Roth
Format: 
Electronic
Published: 2011 (Divergent) 2012 (Insurgent)

 

The premise of this dystopian Young Adult trilogy is straightforward enough.  I’d even argue that it is perhaps too straightforward and therein lies its primary undoing.     The books are based on the idea that future Chicago is divided into clans (here known as “factions”) based SOLELY upon the individual’s personality trait.

The first book is the story of one Special Snowflake called Beatrice who leaves the Abnegation (eg. Quaker) faction of her birth for the more daring Dauntless.   She gives herself the cool, hip new name “Tris”, jumps off a seven-story building into a pit and then makes herself over from a quiet blonde in gray to the kind of person you instinctively avoid on the subway.    Most of the first book chronicles her transition from meek child to what is supposed to be an elite warrior but is really nothing more than a person with uncontrolled impulses toward danger.     Theoretically the Dauntless faction is the security and armed force for this fragmented new Chicago.   Reading the story, however, it’s obvious that Veronica Roth has absolutely no CLUE about how one trains a soldier.  For crying out loud, the bulk of my knowledge in the subject comes from GI Jane and George RR Martin novels and even I know that discipline is the primary skill instilled in any soldier.    Yet the Dauntless faction operates on the exact opposite of discipline, praising people for acting on their most erratic impulses.    That means that fully two thirds of the first book are a frustrating mess of watching punk teenagers get even MORE annoyingly idiotic.     The last third of the book shifts gears entirely, dumping us into the inevitable war between the factions that were originally designed to keep the peace.

I can go on and on about how terrible these two books are, about how incomplete their setup is, about how much they don’t make sense.   But instead I’m going to let you in on a bit of a secret.

These are Christian Fiction.   

In her acknowledgements of the first book,  Veronica Roth says “Thank you, God, for your Son and for blessing me beyond comprehension” .   In the second book she thanks God for “keeping His promises”.   Other than those two sentences there is little mention of religion or faith in the thousand-plus pages of story.   But it’s painfully clear that these are meant as a Christian Fiction-style response to The Hunger Games.     By the middle of Insurgent the messages about peace, sacrifice, character are coming fast and furious.   Roth said that she “[tries] to avoid preaching of any kind” yet these books  read like the author has had a steady diet of heavily-polemic Christian Fiction a la Janette Oke and Ted Dekker.

I’m a devout follower of Christ Jesus, and not ashamed of that fact.   Yet I also make no bones about my extreme dislike for most fiction marketed primarily to Christians.   It has been my experience over the past 40 years of being a reader that much of the fiction sold for Christian audiences is more concerned about re-making the philosophical points found in the Bible than it is about telling a story.    Because of that the stories are often weak, illogical, profoundly uninteresting.      What I find very curious about these two books is just how odd  it is to have the weaknesses so prevalent in Christian-targeted fiction and also to not have the overt “and then Jesus saved all of Chicago” moment.       I find myself wishing that Roth had either decided to write a better series or to make this one more open in its morality play.     As it stands, these first two books in this series are doubly-hollow and wholly illogical.

Advertisements

6 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. Trackback: Sundays With The Bookworm | Just Another Pretty Farce
  2. Trackback: Sundays With The Bookworm | Just Another Pretty Farce
  3. Misheal Crocker
    Aug 13, 2013 @ 17:46:30

    Hey Katherine,

    It looks like our group can’t seem to leave these books alone lol. Mandi has reviewed both of these books before as I have reviewed the first one in the series. Not that it is a big deal, I just find it amusing. Anyway I don’t know if I would classify the book as “Christian Fiction” personally. I’ve actually read LOT of Christian Fiction and I like you am a Christian and don’t find much to be actually good for the same reasons as you.

    I mean yes, the book is written by a Christian author, but that doesn’t make it Christian Fiction. I’m a Christian author and I would not consider the novel I’m working on to be “Christian Fiction”. (Crediting and thanking God doesn’t make a book Christian just as it doesn’t make a song Christian even if the artist thanks God in the thank yous.)

    Typically speaking the content is what defines a book as Christian and based solely on the first book it doesn’t strike me as “Christian” I mean a book can still present morals and the idea of peace and still not be Christian Fiction. Typically speaking I am used to Christian Fiction to being very clear on the whole faith and religion issue or have a very strong harkening to a God-like character such as Aslan in “Chronicles of Narnia or Goel in the “Seven Sleepers Series” that I read as a child. Neither of these aspects were present to me in Divergent and thus I don’t think I agree with the Roth books being classified as “Christian Fiction.”

    Reply

    • Katherine Coble
      Nov 30, 2013 @ 16:50:31

      So how do you feel now that you’ve read Allegiant? Is my theory making more sense now?

      Reply

      • Misheal Crocker
        Jan 13, 2014 @ 04:10:16

        Can’t say as I have not read anything beyond Divergent at this point. If I ever get around to reading the other two books in the series I’ll let you know if my opinion changes.

  4. Trackback: Book Review – Allegiant by Veronica Roth | Book In The Bag

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: